When the night shift came up on the morning of Thursday 14^th November 1872, there was no indication of the events which were to upset the whole village of Pelsall and make it the centre of interest for whole of the Black Country area, and give the local journalists an opportunity to indulge in lurid descriptions of the events and emotions connected with the events.

Sometime before 9.00am some of the one hundred employees in Starkey and Morgan’s Pelsall Hall Colliery had come up for breakfast on the pit bank. At about 9.00am their breakfast break came to a dramatic end with cries of "pull up" from the shaft. Charles Starkey, the manager of the mine for nine months thought the cage might have fallen on someone below. When the cage bonnet appeared, however three men were clinging to it (including Starkey and Stanley), THE MINE WAS FLOODED.

The skip was quickly lowered into the water to find men swimming indiscriminately around and climbing up any support available, keeping themselves above the water level. Some were pulled in by their hair in a spent condition. The skip was lowered again but this time into silence. Twenty-two men were still somewhere in the mine.

Pumping began immediately and went on continuously, day and night. Days and nights of raw drizzling weather, which with the large crowds attracted by the news of the disaster, made the fields and pit bank into a sea of clinging black clayey mud.

There were many mishaps, frustrations and narrow escapes during the rescue operations. In addition to the creaking of the pumping mechanism the rescuers faced the problem of Chokedamp, which lay near the floor of the mine. Messrs Ness, Starkey and Forrester were in the pit on one occasion when Ness dropped his cap into the water. He stooped to recover it inhaled the gas and had to be taken out of the mine. Ness himself had earlier pulled Starkey out of an area where Chokedamp would have killed him.

The inrush of water on that day of the disaster had brought down the roof, by washing away the supporting trees. It was necessary to insert air trows to get the Chokedamp away.

While pumping was underway the Bishop of Lichfield took morning and evening services in the church on Sunday and also addressed workers and spectators on the pit bank.

The Wesleyan Minister Reverend William Winspear followed his example, while students from the theological college made collection boxes and collected from the crowd.

On Monday a fall in the water level encouraged a hope of entry into the flooded and blocked galleries. Sister Dora was invited and a schoolroom was fitted out for the reception of the bodies. In 1872 the main to Pelsall was by rail. The picture, which visitors had of Pelsall at that time, is vastly different from the one we have today.

" The traveler can seen the dense black smoke from the stack from the train. The fires at night on the pit bank highlight the disaster scene: The visitor needs to cross the common, a bare bleak spot full of swamps and pit falls. There is a road, easily found in daylight but after dark a man might find himself over head and ears in some "swag" or lying in some hole with a fractured limb or sprained joint. After the church a little lane brought one to a stile, after which two fields had to be crossed to get to the pit bank. The feet of thousands of visitors and the continuous heavy rain made it impossible to reach the pit bank without being splashed from head to feet. Even supposing one had managed to get there without falling full length".

On Wednesday morning the final signs of hope and despair were confirmed when the pumps brought up a piece of material which turned out to be a watch pocket from a mans trousers. The watch was still in the material and it was confirmed as that of Thomas Starkey. The macabre conclusion was that his body was caught in the pumping mechanism at the bottom of the shaft. The pumping was stopped and the tank went down with messrs., Lindop, Buff and Rounds. Their fears were confirmed and the battered body of Thomas Starkey (18yrs) was brought up, to his waiting father and brothers in the pithead office.

Even by Tuesday the volunteer excavators had made a ten-yard passage along the blocked roadway and on Wednesday afternoon after the delay for the clearance of Chokedamp they reached the gate road where Michael Cash had been working at the time of the disaster. The body of Michael Cash (48yrs) was found lying behind an upturned tub, the bruise on his head showed that he had been thrown against a beam and his arm was wrapped around a prop and entangled in a horse’s reigns. It is assumed that Cash was running away from the torrent that came from his "face". The horse had been working up one of the other gate roads and it was felt that the overturned tub and the horse hampered Cash’s escape.

At 4.20 Mr Ness took down a blanket in which the body was to be brought to the surface and carried along with that of Starkey, in a banksman’s box, to the long room at the Station Hotel. A trap provided by Mr Bamhill served as the transport.

Mr.H.Brookes, George Goring and Mr Lees went down the shaft later in the day to investigate a blockage in the passage between the two shafts.

They made their way into the stables and there found the body of a 14-year-old Thomas Coleman^# hanging by his middle across one of the dividing poles between the stalls.

It is not really such a great coincidence that at that moment Mrs Coleman was reported to be opening the office door on the bank above. On being offered a cup of tea, she refused asking only for "my poor little boy that I may lay out his lifeless body. She had to wait but a short while for her prayer to be answered.

By Friday six days after the initial flooding the water had subsided and been pumped enough for the rescuers to search along the main engine road. The search was taking place ten yards from the shaft bottom when three of the searcher, Goring, Thomas Leased Enoch Jaundrill apparently frustrated with the official route moved off and found a different way into the "crop of the shallow". This was the highest part of the workings; their decision must have caused some alarm because there was concern for their safety when they were known to have gone. Their hazardous mission was successful however and the discovery they made was as equally unnerving, being likened by the reporter to that of the ancient Mariner. The area was dry, as the water had never reached this "refuge". All the bodies found except one were dry and dressed to leave the pit. The other victim appeared to have made his way into the crop through the water. Ten of the men were huddled together with arms entwined either for warm or solace in what they would know to be a desperate situation. Four of the men were sitting in a tub and three other men were sitting in second one. Old man Starkey was lying with his legs inside the tub; it was assumed that he had used his experience to guide the others there. Death had come from the chokedamp, liberated with the pent up waters. Wise after the event one commentator pointed out they could have been saved had Abyssinian Tubes been inserted. There was yet one body to be accounted for, namely that of Stephen Lawton 13yrs who was suspected to be buried under the debris^##. The bodies were brought to the surface in sacks, kindly provided by Mr.S.Birch of Blakenall.

Even this operation was not without hazard for the aperture through which the bodies had to be conveyed was only a few feet in width. One entrance to the crop of the shallow was half way down the shaft. The cage was stopped by a call from inside and whilst the cage was suspended over the void, the miners had to crawl out to reach the entrance hole over a two feet "space" then crawl into the tunnel in inky darkness with only the close presence of colleagues to give them security

Chokedamp was still another danger; it came quickly without warning and could be affect by surface atmospheric pressure. "When the wind blows from Gornal Way, you may leave the pit and go to play", was a common saying.

The bodies recovered were those of: -

Charles Astbury, George Baugh, Charles Capewell, Charles Cash, Michael Cash, George Cassel,

Thomas Coleman, Frank Dilkes, Joseph Hollis, Thomas Hollis, John Hubbard,  Richard Hyde, 

Thomas Orcutt, John Quarters,Tom Richards, John Roberts,  John Starkey, Thomas Starkey,

Thomas Starkey (snr), Edward Williams,  .

The inquest began at the Station Inn with the bodies laid out in the large long room at the back of the Inn, long tables having been erected down both sides of the room for the reception of the bodies. Charles Starkey reported how he had been on hand at the first signs of trouble. How he had helped to rescue the nine men including two of his sons, from the water in the shaft, which was already seven to eight feet deep. He said that earlier before coming up for breakfast there had been no more than the usual amount of water in the mine. He went on to say that most of the work of heading and stalling was in the "crop" the highest part of the mine and twelve to thirteen yards higher than the pit bottom.

Thomas Davies, who had been in the mine at the time of the inrush said he heard a roaring noise from the "jigger hill" or "crop" and ran into the main road. He saw water running along and went to the bottom of the shaft. He managed to keep his head above water while the cage went up and was the last to be rescued. He confirmed Charles Starkey’s evidence that water normally flowed from Michael Cash’s work area and that it was no more than could be expected in any pit. It was drained off down an old road and it was his theory that the miners had hit an old gate road. Harry Astbury had been working thirty yards away from Michael Cash who was heading higher up the "crop". He reported that Cash called to him "Here Harry come and look at the river Dee". Water was coming through an opening "As thick as a mans leg" and there was another one six inches higher up the face not so thick. Astbury remarked that he had never seen such a strong flow before and remarked to Cash that he would not cut one inch of that for a sovereign. Neither sensed any immediate danger, Harry Astbury said his remark was an indication that the damp place was no good for him to be working in. Both men went back to work, fifteen minutes later a fizzing noise was heard. "It’s the water that’s broken in," shouted Cash. Astbury ran to the main gateway, by which time the water was already so strong that it carried him to the shaft bottom.

Isaac Cash the 19-year-old son of Michael Cash, who had thus struck the fateful blow, had also been working in the "jigger hill". The first sign of danger for him was when someone shouted, "Run". The water in the gate road was already over his head. The day before his father’s heading had been dry;

The mine surveyor said that all his records and knowledge showed the land to be Virgin Land but he had heard an old man of ninety say that he "remembered begin told" of old shafts in the area. Starkey had taken over the pit after the lease had been granted to Isiah Morgan in 1869 by John Smith Charles, the landowner and no mention had been made of old workings. When the mine was cleared it was established beyond doubt that Michael Cash had broken into an old gate road running at right angles to his heading. When a Walsall reporter re-visited the pit the following summer he was take down to Cash’s heading and into the "old men’s" workings. Some of the intrepid miners had made their way along these workings as far as their bravery or foolhardiness would allow them and estimated that they had traveled underneath the Church. At one particular spot they found a small man-made recess in the roadside wall in which rested a clay pipe. Presumably this belonged to the old miner of the previous century, whose job it was to keep an eye on the nearby brick built culvert and it’s flow of water, and who made this recess to hold his personal belongings. The clay pipe was later appropriated by one of the many visitors to Mr. Starkey's house.

Another shot hole in Cash’s heading but higher up from the floor had been drilled to within six inches of the "old men’s" workings. Had Michael Cash continued with this drilling instead of moving to another area of the fall, the results of the work may have been totally different. Further confirmation of the age of the workings came from the timbering and the timber used. It constituted a very different method of supporting the roof.

THE OTHER TWO BODIES.

No mention is made to where the other two bodies were recovered from, these being the bodies of; - Stephen Lawton 13yrs and John Heyward 38yrs.

On the first anniversary of the Disaster the colliery, which had re-opened in March 1873, closed for the day. A procession made it’s way from the pit bank over the fields, which had been repaired by farmers and nature during the summer to a service in the church. Afterwards widows and children were given tea in the Wesley schoolrooms supervised by Mr. Barnett and Reverend Winspear.

On the second anniversary of the disaster one hundred workmen from the colliery again moved in procession from the pit to the church. It had been intended to unveil a monument over the vault but this was not quit ready. In the event when the monument was ready there was no ceremony and it’s unveiling went unmarked.

The monument consisted of two slabs of Hollingwood stone, surmounted by an obelisk of Aberdeen granite on which were cut the names of the men who died it was the work of a Wednesbury firm.