As the
score suggests Irish humiliated the Cherry and Whites without too much trouble.
The match was effectively over at half-time with the home side in a commanding
lead 23-3.
The stark reality of the situation was the fact that once again Gloucester’s
pack was not fit for purpose.
Outplayed in every phase of the game.
The scrum was so poor it was an embarrassment, the line-out little better
and the whole team was put under unrelenting pressure throughout.
The simple fact of the matter is the present pack is just not physically
strong enough. It has been said all too often in the past that the grunt
starts up front. Against Irish it was more of a low pitched sigh from Gloucester.
Forced to live off scraps, this Gloucester team looked a very ordinary bunch
of no-hopers and on this form a mid-table Premiership position will take
some securing.
No
forward came up to the mark, the front row outclassed, the second row struggled,
the back row was anonymous and the cause was not helped by continual ill
discipline that resulted in referee Dean Richards issuing four yellow cards
to the visitors on top of the raft of penalties that they conceded.
Is this a record?
At any level of rugby to lose one player is difficult to cope with but for
Gloucester it was an absolute disaster—it seemed that for most of the second
half they only had fourteen players on the pitch.
Both props were changed at the interval but the pack still went back.
Charlie Sharples scored a consolation try but Gloucester looked vulnerable
on the wings against a strong robust back division.
Against a poor Bath side Gloucester looked a decent side but up against
Irish it was completely different. There is no doubt that the Gloucester
team looked a very poor side. Quite how good Irish are remains to be seen
but they were streets ahead of Gloucester in all departments. Men against
boys. A rabble against real rugby.
With the players available at Kingsholm this season it is difficult to see
how the pack can be bolstered and unless there is a dramatic improvement
in the performance of all the forwards it is going to be a very long hard
winter.
Irish were much better at the breakdown where Gloucester struggled with
the almost inevitable slow ball and were never able to secure enough possession
to mount anything like pressure.
It was depressing to watch so-called talented players never look like scoring,
let alone making a contest of the match. However in marked contrast it seemed
that every time Irish launched an attack they looked like scoring.
Ex Gloucester fly-half Ryan Lamb collected 20 points but he had a very easy
time behind his dominant pack.
It was almost like watching a replay of the matches at the end of last season
and Redpath & Co, have a major job on their hands to rebuild the morale
before the Saints come marching in to Kingsholm, doubtless Mr Hartley will
fancy his team’s chances when they have had a look at Gloucester’s video
horror show.
Come to think of it we conceded 42 points to Irish last season and 40 to
Northampton. Let’s hope history doesn’t repeat itself next week.
T.H.-13/9/2009
| GLOUCESTER |
Olly
Morgan |
| Charlie Sharples *Card |
Tim
Molenaar |
| J. Eliota F.Sapolu |
| Tom Voyce |
| Nicky Robinson |
| Rory Lawson |
| Gareth Delve * Card |
| Andy Hazell |
| Alastair Strokosch |
| Alex Brown |
| Dave Attwood |
| Greg Somerville |
| Scott Lawson |
Alasdair
Dickinson |
| Replacements |
| Darren Dawiduik |
| Nick Wood |
| Pierre Capdevielle * Card |
| Marco Bortolami |
| Akapusi Qera *Card |
| James Simpson-Daniel |
| Dave Lewis |
| Freddie Burns |
| Glos Scorers |
Tries:
Sharples |
| Con: Robinson |
Pen:
Robinson |
| Referee - Dean Richards |
| Attendance
- 12,309 |
Pricey's
Postscript
We were lucky it was kept to 40. Irish could have been into the 30's at
half time had they gone for the jugular by kicking penalties for the line-out
rather than the three points.
The pack was demolished at the scrum and the only safe line-out ball was
at the front. I lost count of the penalties conceded for either not releasing
or coming in from the side.
The 3 sin bins were spot on and in Qera's case it should have 20 minutes
for being stupid, too.
Irish moved the ball away from the breakdown very quickly by using their
centres to carve up the mid-field and as a result the defence was always
stretched. .
By
contrast Gloucester kept the ball close to the breakdown and were soon snaffled
out of it.
No doubt the papers will laud Lamb on his performance. He was very efficient
but he could have been wearing carpet slippers and reading the newspaper
from the arm chair ride he got.
Robinson was under pressure all afternoon but all too often for my liking
chose the wrong option. Poorly executed up and unders, rather than kicking
for distance and touch. Trying to run from half-way rather than put the
ball into the corner.
All in all a very poor performance and wake up call that the pack is barely
average and back-up in the three-quarters is thin.
P.S. I understand that there was another yellow card at the end but I was
already out of the ground by then!
John Price
- 13/9/2009
What can one say an ill-disciplined
performance by a side over-run and outplayed in all departments. I said
last week that we looked good against what was a poor Bath side on this
performance we will be joining them nearer to the bottom of the table than
the top. We have let some class players leave the club and replaced them
with mediocre ones. I can't wait for next week there has to be changes and
there has to be a more disciplined approach or Northampton will run in 40+
points.…
Mike
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
| Gloucester pack hammered and humbled | ||
| One way traffic at Reading | ||
| London
Irish 40 Gloucester 10 Madejski Stadium, Reading - Sunday 13 September. 2009 |
||
|
|
||