Insurance Chess Club

http://myweb.tiscali.co.uk/ins.chess

   Matches 2002-03 - Bronowski Trophy Competition

United Banks | Legal | Commercial

Bronowski Trophy Competition 2002-03
Final Table

 

Ins

Legal

Comm

Banks

Total

Games

Insurance

 

7

13½

2

30

Legal

 

11½

2

26½

Commercial

9

 

8

24½

Banks

8

 

½

15

United Banks | Legal | Commercial | Top

United Banks
Played 27th November 2002, at 11 Belgrave Road.

Insurance

v

United Banks

M.C. Rich 190 (B)

1-0

D. Lean - (W)

J.T. Farrand 184

1-0

DEFAULT

D.R. Sedgwick 166

½-½

B. Whitworth 137

D. Malcolm 163

1-0

J.C. Skipworth 127

D.I. Calvert 165

½-½

D. Tidmarsh 131

J.H. Aldred 159

½-½

M.N. Jones 122

I.D. Hunnable 156

1-0

D.R. Chambers 111

A.G.C. Paish 156

1-0

DEFAULT

DEFAULT

0-1

J. Durrans -

M.C. Page 150

1-0

A. O'Dowd 90

P.R. Barclay 147

1-0

DEFAULT

A.R. Kent 141

1-0

DEFAULT

G.W. Naldrett 130

1-0

DEFAULT

C. Bartlett 127

1-0

DEFAULT

S.R. Humphrey 122

1-0

DEFAULT

R.P. Hamilton 119

1-0

DEFAULT

 

13½-2½

 

Report by Geoff Naldrett:

Before the match started United Banks defaulted four boards, so myself, Colin Bartlett, Stephen Humphrey and Ray Hamilton had default wins (the latter three not being required to travel). United Banks then arrived and announced that two more were not coming, so Anthony Kent and Paul Barclay had wasted journeys, the latter from Essex. By the default time, Julian Farrand's and Tony Paish's opponents had not turned up, but neither had Michael Wiltshire, so the match was played over seven boards only.

James Aldred was the first to finish, agreeing a draw with Mike Jones selflessly in order to secure the win of the match! Ian Calvert drew soon afterwards, but word has it that he had earlier turned down the offer of a draw!

Martin Page won on time, but by then was winning anyway.  His opponent had had a king side attack, but it had been just too slow to win, whereas Martin was three pawns up on the queen's side at the end.

John Skipworth tried a speculative bishop sacrifice against David Malcolm, but a quiet move by David won him the game. Mark Rich's game looked fairly even for most of the time, but then his opponent missed a tactic, lost a piece and resigned.David Sedgwick seemed to be having the worse of things for much of the game, but eventually a draw was agreed. Ian Hunnable eventually outplayed Dave Chambers and won more and more material until Dave resigned.

So, we won the match by 13½ to 2½, conceding three draws and one default win. It was a pity that so many games were defaulted and that the match result was, therefore, never in doubt.

GWN

United Banks | Legal | Commercial | Top

Legal League
Played 19th March 2003 at 222 Grays Inn Road.

Insurance

v

Legal

J.T. Farrand 184

1-0

A. Whiteley 192

M.C. Rich 185

1-0

C. Wismayer 176

D. Malcolm 163

0-1

S.J.F. Walsh 146

D.R. Sedgwick 166

½-½

J. Lawrence -

I.D. Hunnable 156

1-0

M. Groom -

A.G.C. Paish 156

0-1

A. McGuinness 150

M.C. Page 150

0-1

J.A. Knott -

J.H. Aldred 159

0-1

H. Mather -

P.R. Barclay 147

0-1

H. Waterman 163

M.R. Wiltshire 146

1-0

M Mourant 123

A.R. Kent 141

½-½

R. Fidler -

G.W. Naldrett 130

1-0

A. Davies -

S.R. Humphrey 126

½-½

P. Ruttley -

W. Diffey -

1-0

T. Olatunji 134

R.P. Hamilton 119

1-0

P. Dodd -

R.F. Collins 107

1-0

D. Tunkel -

 

9½-6½

 

Report from Geoff Naldrett:

This match was played over the full 16 boards, with no defaults.  Although half the Legal League players were ungraded, we knew from previous experience that this didn't necessarily mean that they weren't useful players.

As I played and my opponent moved quickly I didn't have much time to see the other games. 

Stephen Humphrey had a fairly early draw, but Ian Hunnable, Mark Rich and Bob Collins had fairly early wins, then Anthony Kent drew.  William Diffey also won, and things seemed to be going well for us.  David Sedgwick drew, but then David Malcolm, Martin Page, James Aldred (on time) and Paul Barclay all lost.  Another middle order batting collapse!  Ray Hamilton and Julian Farrand then improved our chances by winning.

I then won my quickplay finish, in about 60 moves, with two minutes left on my clock, to give us a winning lead.

In the last games to finish Michael Wiltshire, always good value for the spectators, with never a dull moment, somehow won on time in a quickplay scramble, when he had looked to have been clearly losing for nearly all the game, and Tony Paish lost another quickplay finish.

So a 9½-6½ win, when a narrower win had looked likely.

As Legal had, perhaps surprisingly, beaten Commercial 8½-7½, this meant that we could lose narrowly to Commercial in the last match and still retain the Bronowski Trophy, as long as Legal did not trounce United Banks.

GWN

Games: Farrand-Whiteley | Wismayer-Rich

United Banks | Legal | Commercial | Top

London Commercial Chess League
Played 9th April 2003 at 11 Belgrave Road.

Insurance

v

Commercial

S.H. Berry 210 (W)

1-0

G.A. Harvey 167 (B)

D. Malcolm 163

½-½

P.J. Jaszkiwskyj 154

D.I. Calvert 165

1-0

M. Baker 155

D.R. Sedgwick 166

1-0

B. O'Gorman 150

A.G.C. Paish 152

0-1

S.W. Berkley 146

M.C. Page 151

0-1

S. Barr 150

J.H. Aldred 155

½-½

S. Weston 146

B.W. Atkinson 150

0-1

B.J. Smith 141

M.R. Wiltshire 146

0-1

D.J. Bland 139

A.R. Kent 141

½-½ 

M. Wickham 145

S.R. Humphrey 126

1-0

A. Barron 144

R.P. Hamilton 119

½-½ 

M.J. Broad 139

W. Diffey -

½-½

M.D. Harrison 133

D.S.J. Shipp 109

0-1

F.W. Moreland 136

K.S. Parrott 108

0-1

G.H. Monk 128

R.F. Collins 107

½-½

D.G. Wayte 116

 

7-9

 

Report by Geoff Naldrett:

I tried to have the date of this match rearranged, as I knew we would be short of a number of our stronger players, but to no avail.

Our resounding win against United Banks earlier in the season had, however, meant that  we could lose narrowly to Commercial and still retain the Bronowski Trophy, as long as Legal did not trounce United Banks the same evening.

Julian Farrand and our Wanstead & Woodford players were unavailable, among others, and Mark Rich had to cry off through illness on the day, but I arranged for Kevin Parrott and David Shipp to play at short notice.  Kevin was happy to be a reserve, but I had promised him a game, so stood down myself.

We had the edge on gradings on the higher boards, but Commercial had the edge on the lower boards.

Some of the early results went against us, but Ian Calvert had a nice endgame win and David Sedgwick outplayed Brendan O'Gorman.  Anthony Kent got a lucky draw, Mike Wickham missing a mate, taking a draw by repetition of position instead.

I was regretting standing down when we trailed 4-8, with four games left.  In these games, however, Stephen Berry and Stephen Humphrey outplayed their opponents in the quickplay finish, James Aldred agreed a draw (though this gave Commercial the match) and Ray Hamilton, who had looked to be clearly winning earlier, managed to draw his game, though conceding 20 grading points.

So, 3/4 from the last four games and a 7-9 loss, when a bigger loss had seemed possible. 

I learnt the next morning that Legal had beaten United Banks 11½-4½, with the result that we had retained the Bronowski Trophy by 30 game points to 26½, both ICC and  Legal having won two matches and lost one.

A closer shave than I would have liked!

GWN