Home
Up

 

 

 

 

 

This page is intended to answer some of your questions about processors and how to compare them. Click on the questions to jump directly to the answers.

What do all these processors mean?

Processor Speed

One Core or More?

What RAM?

What Hard Disk?

Graphics

Which Operating System

 

 

What do all these processors mean?

The processor is the main brain in the computer. There are 2 main manufacturers Intel and AMD.

Both these manufacturers have a range of different processors, some are single, dual triple and quad core. This means effectively multiple processors on the same chip so they will multi task better, whether they make a particular program run better depends very much on how that program was designed. If the program is designed to share out the work between different processors, it will run better on a multi core, if not, it may run better on a faster chip with fewer cores. We frequently see quad core processors at  a slower clock speed than a cheaper dual core, for many games it may be better to go for the faster dual core. The difference is often slight however and in the long term multi core processors are going to win.

Intel.

Intel has 5 main groups:

    Atom

        The Atom is widely used in netbooks and some of the latest ultra compact desktop computers.  It's a single core, most common   clock speed is 1.6Ghz, it's biggest advantage is very low power consumption and low heat build up. It is perfectly adequate for running windows XP and so they say the forthcoming Windows 7. This processor will seriously struggle with Vista however.

    Celeron

The Celeron is the budget chip from Intel, now available in single and dual core and a variety of clock speeds. Obviously the higher the clock speed the better, Runs XP, Vista or Windows 7 perfectly happily, best to go for at least 2GB RAM with vista. Good for office applications, photo editing etc, start to struggle on the faster games and video editing.

    Pentium

The Pentium is still available but will be replaced by the Core processors eventually. Once the flagship of the Intel range, the Pentium dual core is still a very good processor.

    Core

Available in Dual Core, Quad Core and now the latest i7 range. The i7 range uses the latest technology to make the tracks and components on the chip even smaller resulting in more transistors etc to give more processing power while reducing electrical power consumption. The down side is the latest thing is always expensive, prices are likely to drop in a few months.

Xeon

The xeon is used mainly in servers and is available in dual and quad core

 

AMD

AMD's budget range is the Sempron then there's the Athlon single and dual core and the Phenom. There is also the Opteron which is used mainly for servers

    Sempron

All single core, range of processor speeds very good budget processors, run XP, vista or Windows 7 no problem, as above best to go for at least 2GB RAM with vista. As with the Celeron, good for office applications, photo editing etc, start to struggle on the faster games and video editing.

    Athlon

There are 2 flavours of Athlon, the LE (low energy) and the X2 dual core. Both are very capable chips, the high speed X2 processors like the 7800 are very good for gaming.

Phenom

The phenom is available in triple and quad core. The triple core is really a quad core with 1 core disabled. A variety of speeds is available. Generally the Phenom offers more "Bang per buck" than the Intel core quad processors. Both are extremely good but you tend to get a bit more for the money with AMD. 

Return to the Top

Processor Speed

The speed of the processor is the "clock speed" or the frequency at which the processor operates. In broad terms, the faster the clock speed (this is the 2.4 or 2.8Ghz you see mentioned), the faster the computer goes - in broad terms. Beware that some manufacturers put fast processors like a 3.0 GHz Pentium into a budget PC to make the advert look good, this is called "Going for the Headline". Certainly, this will perform quite well but not nearly as well as if you put the same processor on a really good motherboard with a really good graphic card, lots of RAM and a high speed hard disk. Overall speed is a combination of all these things

It gets a bit more complicated when we talk about the architecture of the chip and the amount of cache memory is built into it. Sufficed to say that a 1.7Ghz Pentium or Core is faster than a 1.7 Ghz Celeron even though they have the same clock speed.

When we compare the Intel to the AMD, AMD say their method of doing calculations is different and so ends up with better performance at a lower clock speed. To be fair, all the benchmarking tests carried out by magazines and so on bear this out. So, we end up with the Athlon XP getting numbers like 5400, 7750 etc at first they put these numbers to line up with the Pentiums but now there seems to be very little analogy. The only way to do a direct comparison is to look at a test such as http://www.cpubenchmark.net/index.php even tests like these can be quite difficult to interpret, what we always try to do is get the best value, the very latest thing is usually the fastest but it's also 5 times the price of one that's been around for a few months.

Return to the Top

Return to the Top

What RAM?

RAM is Random Access Memory, the processor does all the calculations and is discussed above but it needs to be fed data to work on in a constant stream. RAM is the fastest way of doing this, if you can hold lots of stuff in RAM, the data transfer rate to the processor is very quick. If the computer runs out of space in RAM, it saves some data down onto the hard disk into the Windows "Swap File". Even with a really fast hard disk this is much, much, much slower than reading it straight from RAM. there are however lots of different types of RAM, again its' speed is measured as the frequency it operates at. There are also physical differences in the type of slot they fit into.

Older computers (usually Pentium 100, 133 or earlier ) may still have 72 pin DIMMS ran at 33Mhz

Then came 168 pin SDRAM this started at 66 Mhz and the most recent is the PC133 (133 Mhz)

After that was DDR or double data rate RAM and is called PC2100 (266Mhz), PC2700 (333Mhz) and lately PC3200 (400Mhz).

Next was DDR2 at speeds up to 800Mhz

The latest one is DDR3, which started out last year at very high prices but has now become more reasonable

Basically, the faster the better and the more you have the better. For most purposes these days 512MB is the norm and is more than adequate, Windows 98 will run quite happily with anything more than 32 and XP should have at least 256. To give you an idea, my first PC had 4 MB and that was a lot at the time. Given the current prices of RAM, we recommend Minimum of 512 for XP, 1GB is better and minimum 1GB for Vista, 2GB is better. Going above 3GB is pointless unless you have a 64 bit operating system, a 32 bit operating system cannot recognise more than 4GB, see the Which operating system section. 

 

Return to the Top

Graphics

The Graphics or Video card is what sends the picture to your monitor.

Games that are really heavy on graphics especially 3D like Quake or the latest driving games would benefit from a better graphics card and a faster processor. The better your graphics card, the smoother your moving images will be, for most ordinary applications it's hard to tell the difference from one graphics card to another.

Many of the motherboards in our (and most other suppliers) systems have built in graphics cards which use some of the system memory (RAM) for operation. A few years ago, generally this meant poorer performance, and it was far better to have a separate graphics card with its' own memory. Bear in mind that I'm talking about computers that had 16 or 32 MB of RAM and graphics cards with only 2 or 4 MB.

Nowadays, the onboard graphics have improved greatly, the system RAM is faster and there is a lot more of it so using some of it for video is not as important. You can always add a graphics card if you want to at a later date and disable the onboard graphics but for 90% or more of people and applications, onboard graphics are sufficient.

Generally speaking, if you want a computer for general purposes, onboard graphics are fine, for gaming, go for one with a separate graphic card.

Return to the Top

Hard Disk

The hard disk is where all your information and programs are stored. The amount of storage space you have is measured in GigaBytes (GB) One Gigabyte is about 1000 Megabytes (MB). Early hard drives were 30 or 40 MB, even a couple of years ago a 6 GB drive was really big. Now the minimum is 80GB and most systems have 160GB or more.

For most people 160GB is plenty. If you want to edit video or store lots of music or pictures on your hard drive then you may need a larger drive (they're not physically bigger, they all look the same on the outside).

The other important aspect of hard drives is the speed of data access. This is governed by the design of the drive and the speed of rotation of the disks. The latest disks run at 7200 RPM, slightly slower ones run at 5400 RPM. The greatest significance with hard drives at the moment is IDE or SATA - IDE is the older type with a 40 or 80 way ribbon cable (looks like a 2 inch wide ribbon) SATA is newer technology and has much faster data transfer. There is also now SATA II - a bit faster again.

The importance of this access time is touched on in What RAM? above, basically windows uses RAM first to keep data in memory, when there's not enough RAM left, it writes some of the data down to the hard drive and reads it back when necessary. You also need to read lots of stuff from the hard drive in the first place. This process of reading data is much slower than reading directly from RAM even with a really fast hard disk, so this can be a bottleneck in your system.

Overall then, you need a hard disk with enough space on it to keep all your programs and files and the faster the access time the better.

Which Operating System

There are 4 main choices for operating systems, Apple, Linux and Microsoft XP or Vista

Apple

Apple is available on Apple Mac laptop or Desktop computers, some Apple computers now also have the possibility of a dual boot, to run either XP or the Apple OS. We don't usually sell Apple computers but can get them if desired. Apple computers are widely used in the graphics and publishing domains, they tend to be more expensive than PCs. Personally I prefer Microsoft but it's a question of what you're used to and what suits you.

Linux

Linux was created by Linus Torvalds and released as an open source operating system. This means he made the source code available to anyone so they could use it or add to and improve it. As a result there are several versions or distros available, usually as free downloads from the internet. Most of them include some programs like Open Office. Linux is reasonably easy to install but be prepared fro some searching to solve problems like drivers etc. Since there is no single manufacturer, help usually comes from forums on the net. For something that's free Linux is very very good but if you want ease of use and universal compatibility, windows is better. Many netbooks now come with Linux preinstalled, this keeps the price down but if you prefer Windows, double check before picking up a bargain.

Windows XP or Vista

The current operating system from Microsoft is Vista. Many people have had problems with vista and some have decided to go back to XP. Vista is a more demanding operating system than XP and needs a good processor and preferably at least 2GB RAM to run well. If you're thinking of upgrading the operating system from XP to Vista, our advice would be not to bother as it will probably run slower than XP on an older machine. Because of the bad press vista got in its' first year, many manufacturers started offering Vista or XP in their new computers. Microsoft have said that they will continue to support XP until 2013 so it's got a while yet.

At the end of this year Vista's replacement, Windows 7 is expected. It is already available in a test version for download from Microsoft and we have installed and tested it on several machines. It does seem better than Vista, not as demanding and easier to use.

  Return to the Top

 

Send mail to webmaster@pcofmind.biz with questions or comments about this web site.
Last modified: 16 July 2006